Sam Harris is the now famous author of "The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason
Here you will see Sam Harris briefly discussing the link between religion and violence.
Get the Flash Player to see this player.
Related posts:
Sam Harris–Link Between Religion And Violence
Did you enjoy this post? Why not leave a comment below and continue the conversation, or subscribe to my feed and get articles like this delivered automatically each day to your feed reader. If you don't have a feed reader, you can always have these articles delivered to your email inbox every day. Click here to sign up.
he’s good. About time someone with a little fame said it :)
on a side note, gasmonso, slow down a bit, it’s getting harder and harder to say something meaningfull on the posts. Two/Three a day, you must have a lot of spare time.
Hahaha, I know Acari. I have tended to post a little on the slow side to allow people time to discuss. However, there is so much to report on that it’s difficult to restrain myself.
I am trying to determine a better way to report on more while still retaining some sort of intimacy.
If anyone has ideas please use the contact page and let me know :)
gasmonso
Thanks for sharing this, gasmonso. I was unaware of Sam Harris until now. I’ll have to go buy his books now.
On the side note, I’m torn. I like more articles but I do miss the in depth discussions that followed some of them. We do still have some in depth conversations, but less frequently now because the new news creates new postings that push replies within discussion off of the recent post list.
Perhaps this problem could be reduced is you kept all responses until they reach a certain age instead of keeping the X most recent ones.
Interesting thoughts Sidfaiwu. Would I could do is maintain a list of active posts. That way people could see very easily what posts are happening.
Currently I show the recent comments, but I could have another display of active posts.
gasmonso
Well i’d say it’s “Easier said then done” http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=196404&cid=16091759
Yeah, it’s freaky when people follow you around online, I swear it’s pure coincidense. I’m a long time lurker on /..
anyway back on track.
I would love to know if his books are as good this little interview, or if it’s simply spewing crap all over the USA. Unfortunatly the local library doesn’t have it (again) so it means yet another trip to the book store.
Having just come out of a discussion of some born again moslem seeing this was quite a relief!
How much time do these religious bastards need to see that we don’t want to be saved and that they can’t be racist just because god is with them!
born-again-moslem: simply because i believe and you’re an atheist i’m a hundred times better than you!
(Torah) I chose you to be a special race
(Bible) You are the slat of the sea, you are the light of the world
(Quran) You are the best people that were brought unto the world
(Hitler) The Aryan race is determined to be the leading race on earth
sorry for the bad translation, my arabic isn’t as good as my english
(i hope this doesn’t invoke godwin’s law)
Does anybody see the anology? And those people are allowed to walk freely through the streets!
i’m so pissed off right now! not at the fact that people are still racist, but at the thought that i have ignorant nazis running through the streets and riding the same buses i do!
Mohammed, please come back, your fellow worshippers are ignorant nazis, you need to get some brain into their heads!
ah my fault, i think i tossed a dozen or so that have yet to be put up ^^;
45% of people think Jesus will be coming back in the next 50 years? Interesting, especially since Christians have thought Jesus was “coming back soon” for the past, oh, couple thousand years?
Also, something I noticed as a student of politics: the countries mentioned as being the most aethiestic also happen to be for the most part (I don’t know about Iceland) socialist. I wonder, would the removal of worship of God lead to worship of the state instead? I’m not trying to debate the points of communism v. democracy here, but I know that the government plays a much bigger role there than in the US, for example. So, I wonder if the greater role of states is a result of the loss of a religious power, or an effect of greater human self-consciousness(ie, more confidence in man on earth, so to speak)?
Snurp,
Perhaps it has to do with the poor finally being freed of the promise that their reward is in death. If one doesn’t believe in the afterlife they are more inclined to do all they can to make their life better. Participating in the political process by the poor would certainly result in a more socialist-natured state. Once the gap between rich and poor is made smaller everything should fall into place; lower crime rates, greater equality, etc.
Of course an anarcho-capitalist would wholly disagree. They’d affirm the idea that the people are simply worshipping the state. The state is much more worthy of worship than god at least. The state exists (though again, the an-cap would disagree).
It would be an interesting thesis though to track the development of one of the more atheistic states. What was the series of developments that led to their current success? Hmmm.
“Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, just as it is the spirit of a spiritless situation. It is the opium of the people.”
-Karl Marx, the father of socialism
Socialism and anti-religious sentiment have gone hand and hand since the idea was invented.
sidfaiwu,
You can get some insight into whether or not you’d like Sam Harris on his website (http://www.samharris.org). He’s got lots of essays/articles he’s written and interviews he’s given posted.
The main concept he is pushing is that religion should be subject to the same evidence based inquirey that all other facits of human discovery are subject to. One of his examples is that if you tell someone that 1+1=3 or that his wife is cheating on them, he requires proof, but if you tell him that eating a cracker every Sunday makes a deity happy, he doesn’t require any sort of investigation into the claims. Harris says that this is dangerous because this lack of reason and rationality causes people to become suicide bombers or ignore rational evidence that their religious beliefs are actually hurting people like Catholics do with African condom usage.
He also suggests that we should scientifically explore religious experiences. He says things like meditation can help people understand stuff better; but he says that people who use prayer need to realize that they could have an experience just as profound by gazing at nature or through other religions- that the experience isn’t in any way related to the dogma of their institutions.
Thanks for the info, GlitchCog. I’ll check out the essays.
Sidfaiwu,
I’m not so sure about socialism and anti-religious feelings. Although I can’t confirm this, I think that a lot of early Christian societies are seen now as communistic in nature, as the believed in communal use of goods. There were also groups like the Diggers, who believed that the earth belonged to every one. I know for sure that the idea goes back a lot further than Marx, but he is certainly the most responsible for the current concept.
I think Marx’s idea came from looking at older feudal societies, and seeing the obsession with religion then as a way to control the peasants. For him religion may have still been a tool to simply distract people from their state of oppression, only now the capitalists were using it instead of feudal lords. His “revolutionary class consciousness” could not proceed until people cast off this set of ideas justifying their current misery.
But at the same time, communism in Marx’s eyes and modern socialism are not the same thing. Modern socialism keeps the government, and in fact gives it more power in the form of welfare policy. I saw a study not too long ago that said as people became more economically secure, the percent who believed in religion and its tenets went down. It might just be that greater security leaves no pressing need to believe in God (with America being the exception, apparently), leaving the European socialist countries, who have expansive welfare and insurance policies, feeling both more secure and less God-fearing.
Hello Snurp,
I, in fact, agree with you. Marx and others consider religion as a tool used by authoritarian governments of all kinds. He believed (incorrectly) that the more socialist a government is, the less authoritarian it is. He also believed that in a non-authoritarian government would not see any advantage in maintaining or promoting religion. Thus, to Marx, more socialism leads to less religion.
I should not have written ‘anti-religious sentiment’ but, perhaps ‘non-religious government’.
This is a little disconcerting to me. I am an Atheist, yet I don’t like socialism. I am a capitalist. But:
No pure system, whether it is capitalist, communist, democratic, socialist, or whatever, can survive. A working system will HAVE to have aspects of all of them to work. It may slant in one direction as ours does toward capitalism. It is just a matter of degrees. I would NOT want to live in a mostly socialist system. Nor would I in a fully capitalist one.
Sounds like an interesting book …
But although I’m agnostic and see the vices and severe flaws of religious extremism, as well as the advantages the of separation of religion and state, I’m VERY reluctant to categorize ALL kinds of religious belief as being inherently flawed and the absence of religious faith as being universally better. I would not want to live in a society like the Soviet Union where religion was banned or strongly discouraged even though I myself am not a religious person.
Sam Harris seems to imply that religion is universally a bad thing … but I suppose I’ll have to read his books to get a better idea of where he’s coming from.
For those of you that hate religion and Christian fundamentalism due to bad experiences with religious nutjobs, harsh upbringing, or the Christian political right wing trying to break the separation of church and state, I do sympathize. But I’ve lived in the USA all my life, spent time in California and Texas. I’ve seen Christians believe and act on a wide spectrum of ideals from racism, intolerance, to “end of the world” obsession, to racial harmony, community outreach, selfless charity work and disaster relief. From mindless consumerism and total disregard for the environment to environmental conservationalism. Christian fundamentalists have seemingly been at war with science and yet many of the great scientists, inventors, and philosophers throughout history were Christian.
So I guess I’m trying to say it’s not fair or accurate to say that religion always leads to bad things. Just like people get carried away with religious extremism, people can get carried away with religion phobia as well and unfairly blame all kinds of social ills solely on religion when underlying causes are usually far more complicated. I kinda like this site but do think some people take anti-religious sentiment too far. Whether Sam Harris does or not … I guess I’ll have to read his book.
I enjoyed reading John Piper’s thoughts on browsing through Harris’ book; just thought I’d share them:
http://www.desiringgod.org/ResourceLibrary/TasteAndSee/ByDate/2006/1839_Meditations_After_a_Monday_at_Barnes_and_Noble/
God site. Thanks!
Thank God someone said it.
Its so relieving to hear someone with their head screwed on straight to show that inreality is that organized religions are some of the most counter-productive organizations on earth.
I have a good friend at work, who isn’t very educated, and is quite poor who has recently attached himself to the bible like it was one of his major organs.
He used to be a more level headed man, and now he’s starting to sound more and more like an obsessed nut. I really think he like many other people out there, use the bible-thumping practice as a way to “escape” from the reality that his life really is in total shambles( and it is, he’s got five kids to take care of, a psycho-ex wife harrassing him for money, who takes care of two of the children whom are neglected. He lives in a crime-infested neighborhood in L.A., has no money, has an outstanding debt which is in collections, and a crappy job with no real future)
It makes me really sad to see someone do this, because I can’t even stand to talk to him anymore.
He’s a good example of what i believe happens to so many people who become highly religious.
I finally got around to reading his first book (read the “Letter…” a while back) just recently and i was generally very impressed.
Some of the more hardcore philosophical concepts at the end went over my head, but his chapter on “The Problem with Islam” and section exploring the ethics of ‘justified’ use of torture to save lives was certainly eye opening and challenging – in the best sense though!
Ive since bought it for a good friend who enjoys joining me in these topics of discussion… Hats off Sam Harris!